Ultimate Homemade Stromboli Recipe: A Step-by-Step Guide

by | Jun 23, 2023

If you’re passionate about Italian cuisine, mastering the art of a homemade stromboli recipe is an essential skill. 

This blog post will explore the techniques required to craft your own stromboli from start to finish, focusing on both store-bought and homemade pizza dough options.

A step-by-step guide will walk you through rolling and baking techniques that ensure a tight roll without breakage while achieving that golden crisp crust. 

Finally, in order to appreciate our beloved Stromboli even more, we’ll delve into its historical origins and compare it with its close cousin – the calzone.

man kneading pizza dough

Understanding Homemade Stromboli

If you’re a fan of Italian-American cuisine, then making homemade stromboli is definitely worth exploring. This delicious dish, often filled with various meats and cheeses, is as versatile as it gets – serving perfectly as either a hearty meal or an appetizer for game day snacks.

Overview of Homemade Stromboli

The beauty of strombolis lies in their simplicity. With only six components (flour, yeast, sugar, salt, water and olive oil), this pizza-dough-based treat just needs one rising period – leaving plenty of time to get your fillings ready while the dough rises.

You can experiment with different types of cheese like mozzarella or provolone; add cured meats such as salami or ham; throw in some veggies if you prefer – the possibilities are endless. 

The key here is to balance out your flavors well so that no single ingredient overpowers another.

The process involves rolling out your prepared pizza dough into a rectangle shape before layering on your chosen fillings. 

Once everything’s layered up nicely, all that’s left to do is roll it back up into its iconic log shape before baking until crispy golden brown.

Why Make Homemade Stromboli?

Aside from being a delicious and versatile dish, making homemade stromboli is also a great way to impress your friends and family. 

Invite your loved ones to join in the culinary adventure of creating homemade stromboli. And let’s be real, who doesn’t love a good stuffed pastry?

Not to mention, making your own stromboli allows you to control the quality of ingredients and customize it to your liking. 

You can even make it healthier by using whole wheat flour or adding in some fresh veggies.

Tips for Making the Perfect Stromboli

  • Don’t overstuff your stromboli or it may burst open while baking.
  • Make sure to seal the edges of your stromboli well to prevent any filling from leaking out.
  • Brush the top of your stromboli with an egg wash or a coating of oil to get that perfect, golden-brown hue.
  • Let your stromboli cool for a few minutes before slicing into it to prevent the filling from oozing out.

So what are you waiting for? Whip up a homemade stromboli today and enjoy a delicious and satisfying meal or snack.

Making Stromboli From Pizza Dough

When it comes to making stromboli, the pizza dough is your canvas. Whether you choose a store-bought option or decide to prepare your own from scratch, both paths lead to delicious results.

Store-Bought vs Homemade Pizza Dough: Convenience vs Control

The choice between store-bought and homemade pizza dough often boils down to convenience versus control. 

While pre-made options save time and effort, creating your own gives you full command over the texture and flavor of your base. 

It’s also an opportunity for those with dietary restrictions or preferences to make adjustments as needed.

Preparing The Perfect Pizza Dough For Strombolis

Creating your own pizza dough isn’t as difficult as it may appear; you just need six simple ingredients and a bit of time for rising. For the perfect pizza dough, you’ll need flour, yeast, water, salt, sugar, and olive oil.

Once mixed properly (you can find a detailed guide on how-to here at our Perfect Homemade Pizza Dough Guide), allow about 60-90 minutes for rising time – the perfect window for preparing other elements of your meal.

A key tip when working with any type of pizza dough is letting it rest before shaping; this allows gluten strands within the mixture to relax, resulting in easier rolling and stretching. Remember, patience yields the best results.

In essence, whether opting for a store-bought version or embracing the challenge by kneading one yourself, ensuring a quality base sets the stage for successful stromboli creation. So go ahead and unleash your inner pizzaiolo tonight.

all you knead is love sign

Choosing Your Stromboli Fillings

When it comes to picking what goes in a stromboli, the options are seemingly infinite. 

Almost any ingredient that works on a pizza would work in a stromboli too. But don’t overstuff it or you’ll have trouble rolling up the dough.

Homemade strombolis are versatile. Experiment with different meats like pepperoni, salami, ham, or sausage. For vegetarians, mushrooms or bell peppers make great alternatives.

Cheese is crucial. Mozzarella is traditional, but try provolone, cheddar, or even ricotta for an interesting twist.

How much filling is just right?

Finding the perfect balance between dough and stuffing might seem tricky at first, but practice makes perfect. Aim for about 1 cup total ingredients per every 10-inch piece of rolled-out pizza dough. 

Remember, excessive stuffing could lead to difficulty rolling up neatly without breakage. So always ensure enough space around edges before starting the rolling process. Happy cooking.

Incorporating Sauce into Your Filling

Tailoring your stromboli to fit your personal palate can be a real game-changer. 

Adding sauce directly into your filling mix is a great way to add extra flavor and moisture. 

It’s not mandatory, but it certainly takes your homemade stromboli from good to great.

Sauce Recommendations for Different Types of Fillings

If you’re using traditional Italian meats like salami or pepperoni in your filling, a classic tomato marinara sauce would be an excellent choice. The tangy acidity pairs well with the rich flavors of these meats and creates a balanced bite.

For those who prefer chicken as their protein source, consider using a creamy alfredo or pesto sauce instead. 

These sauces complement the milder flavor profile of chicken while adding richness and creaminess to each slice.

Veggie lovers might enjoy experimenting with different types of sauces too. A sweet barbecue sauce could work wonders with bell peppers and onions, while a spicy arrabbiata might pair perfectly with mushrooms and olives.

Remember – balance is crucial when creating culinary masterpieces. The key here is not just choosing any random sauce but selecting one that complements the other ingredients in your filling mix.

Don’t forget about cheese. Whether you’re opting for mozzarella, provolone, or even ricotta – cheese plays an essential role in holding everything together once rolled up inside our pizza dough blanket. So don’t skimp on this ingredient.

Rolling and Baking a Perfect Stromboli: A Step-by-Step Guide

Do not be daunted by the challenge of crafting a homemade stromboli; with proper guidance, you can produce an exquisite Italian-American delicacy that will wow your guests. 

Creating a scrumptious Italian-American meal that will leave your guests in awe is achievable with the right methods. Here’s how:

Rolling Technique Tips and Tricks

Using a lightly floured surface, roll out the pizza dough into an approximate 10×16 inch rectangle. 

Don’t worry about making it perfect – a rustic shape adds to its charm. Just make sure it’s thin enough to roll easily but thick enough to hold the fillings.

Ensuring a Tight Roll Without Breakage

To prevent breakage when rolling up your stromboli, spread garlic butter over the rolled-out dough and sprinkle fresh herbs evenly across. Layer on your choice of meats and cheeses, leaving about an inch around the edges free from filling. This allows space for sealing later.

Gently start rolling one long edge towards the other side as tightly as possible without tearing or squeezing out any stuffing. 

Once fully rolled, tuck the ends underneath to create a cylindrical shape that’s ready for baking. Brush egg wash all over for a golden sheen post-bake.

Tips for Achieving a Golden, Crispy Crust

Bake your stromboli in a preheated oven at 375°F (190°C) for about 25-30 minutes until it turns beautifully golden brown. 

For extra crispy crusts like those found in professional pizzerias, consider using a pizza stone instead of a regular baking tray.

Remember, patience is key here – don’t rush the process or you risk ending up with a soggy, undercooked pastry or, worse, burnt ones. Happy cooking.

Difference Between Calzone And Stromboli

When it comes to Italian cuisine, calzones and strombolis are two popular dishes that often get confused. Despite their similarities, these stuffed pastries have distinct characteristics that set them apart.

Historical Origins of Both Dishes

The calzone, which translates to “trouser” or “stocking” in Italian, originated from Naples. This half-moon shaped pastry is traditionally filled with ingredients like ricotta cheese, mozzarella, ham, or salami.

In contrast, the stromboli was created by Nazzereno Romano in Philadelphia during the 1950s. 

Named after the movie ‘Stromboli’, this dish features a rolled-up crust filled with various meats and cheeses before being baked until crispy.

Detailed Comparison of Shape and Fillings

Apart from their origins and shapes – calzones being folded over into a semi-circle while strombolis are rolled up like logs – there’s also a difference when it comes to fillings used. 

Traditional calzones don’t usually include tomato sauce inside; instead, they’re served with marinara on the side for dipping purposes, whereas you’ll find sauce within most stromboli recipes.

  • Calzone: Semi-circular shape; typically includes ricotta cheese along with other fillings but no internal sauce
  • Stromboli: Rolled log-like shape; can be filled with any pizza toppings including sauces

Take a look at our Stromboli vs Calzone: A Delicious Debate here.

No matter your preference between these two delicious options, remember: whether you’re making homemade strombolis using pizza dough or trying out traditional Neapolitan-style calzones, both offer endless possibilities for customization.

A flaming pizza oven


Are you tired of the same old pizza routine? Try stromboli for a change of pace and a burst of flavor. 

Mastering the art of making homemade Stromboli will undoubtedly elevate your cooking skills and bring joy to your dining table. 

With a few simple ingredients and some creative flair, you can create a delicious, customizable Stromboli that will impress your guests and leave them craving more. 

So, roll up your sleeves, gather your ingredients, and embark on a culinary adventure with this ultimate homemade Stromboli recipe.

Written By SEODave777

David Nilsson is the founder of The SEO Back Office and former SEO agency Converted Click. Passionate about people, search engines, faith, technology and boxing.

Related Posts

Thin Crust Pizza Dough Recipe

Thin crust pizza dough recipe Need to know how to make a thin-crust pizza dough recipe? Stop wasting time, follow this guide: Making your own pizza or...