Next Level Homemade Pizza Toppings – for No Fuss and Max Taste

by | Aug 6, 2023

This resource is an extensive list of easy, homemade pizza toppings you can easily find lying around your kitchen.

Plus making your own pizza or dough at home tastes amazing, and is super fun! Jump into these homemade pizza toppings now.


Are you looking for new pizza toppings to try in the comfort of your own home!

These homemade pizza topping ideas can help create fresh and flavorful options. Release your creative flare, dare a little, and combine them in a way you love!

Trusted Homemade Pizza Toppings

Let's jump in to our favourite list of homemade pizza toppings you can use today!

Roasted Veggies

When making pizza at home, it is typically recommended to bake it for a few minutes, usually around 10-13 minutes in a 500°F oven. If the vegetable toppings are not cut into smaller pieces, they may not cook thoroughly in that time and could potentially release water onto the pizza.

Roasted cherry tomatoes are a popular option for homemade pizza toppings. The cherries have a distinct flavor and texture that complement different pizza toppings.

  • Roasted Red Peppers: Always a solid choice. Pat the peppers dry and thinly slice them before piling them onto your pizza.
  • Baby artichokes: Fresh baby artichokes have a limited season, so it's recommended to add them to your pizza while they are available. The halves are roasted and then either quartered or roughly chopped before being baked on a pizza.
  • Roasted Butternut Squash: Perfect for fall or winter pies! It's delicious with sage, red onion, and vegan cashew cream.
  • Roasted brocolli: To roast the broccoli, cook it until the florets have a slight browning. The pizza toppings will get browner on top.
  • Roasted Fennel: Fennel seed is commonly used in sausage recipes. One option is to roast it in wedges. You should chop them into small pieces before adding them to your pizza.
  • Roasted cauliflower: is a delicious and underrated vegetable pizza topping, with its nutty and caramelized flavors.
  • Mushrooms: Earthiness that pairs well with cheeses like mozzarella or feta.
  • Bell peppers: Vibrant colors plus unique sweet crunch equals deliciousness.
  • Onions: Caramelized sweetness when cooked; sharp freshness when raw.
  • Olives: Salty bites bringing tanginess balancing out rich cheese flavors perfectly.
  • Tomatoes: Fresh tomatoes lending juiciness while sun-dried versions offer concentrated tomato flavor.

Home Made Pizza Toppings Lying Around in Your kitchen

Have you looked through your food drawers recently, fridge or veggie draws to see what you may have left over or forgotten about? You will be suprised at what home made pizza toppings you may find. Let's start with some veggies.

Uncooked Vegetables

Think you know all about vegetable toppings for your homemade pizza? Well, let's elevate that knowledge to the next level.


The Mighty Mushroom:

You might be used to throwing mushrooms on top of your pie. But did you ever stop and think about how their earthy flavor adds a whole new dimension?

Bell Peppers

Crispy Crunch with Bell Peppers:

A bell pepper isn't just another veggie topping. It's a game changer. Its sweet crunch can transform an ordinary pizza into something extraordinary.

Tips for Adding Vegetables to Your Pizza:

  1. Sauteing certain veggies like mushrooms beforehand helps remove excess moisture which could otherwise make your pizza soggy.
  2. Veggies prone to wilting (like spinach) should be added halfway through cooking time so they retain some structure without burning up completely.
  3. Fresh herbs such as basil work best sprinkled over the top after baking - this way their delicate aroma isn't lost during high oven temperatures.

To really take things up a notch, don't just stick to one type of vegetable per pie. Mix it up. Add different combinations every time you bake and discover amazing tastes along the way.


Let's talk pineapple, the controversial pizza topping that has split opinions worldwide. This tropical fruit brings a unique twist to homemade pizzas with its sweet and tangy profile.

Sweet and Savory Balance

When you bite into a slice pineapple there is an unexpected burst of flavor where the natural sugars counteract the rich savoriness from other ingredients like cheese or ham.

Beyond tantalizing our taste buds though, let's also look at how these juicy fruits contribute positively towards maintaining good health. Pineapples are packed full of vitamin C - essential for immune system support - along with manganese which aids bone health according to Healthline's article about benefits eating pineapples.

You can really get creative when prepping pineapples for your homemade pizzas. Some folks love using fresh chunks straight off the core while others prefer canned pieces which tend to be softer due to their syrup preservation process.

Must read: 18 Best Pizza Flavors You Need to Try (Some May Shock You)

But here's something even more interesting: why not grill those slices before they hit your dough? You'll add another layer of complexity by introducing subtle hints of charred goodness.

Artichoke Hearts

Step into the world of Homemade pizza toppings and let's uncover the magic of artichoke hearts.

First off, if canned/jarred versions are being used, drain properly so as not to make the dough soggy. Remember, less is more when adding toppings; too many could result in uneven cooking time and overwhelm other flavors.

And while pre-cooking isn't necessary, lightly sauteing prior to baking enhances the overall flavor profile, giving softer bites.

The Subtle Savoriness

Avoiding an overpowering taste, these humble vegetables bring a unique flavor to your home-cooked pizzas. They blend effortlessly with other ingredients on your pie, making them a versatile topping choice.

Mix it up with cheese or pesto sauce, you'll find that their mildness complements both beautifully.

Cheese: The Perfect Partner for Artichokes

Dive deeper into pairing cheeses with artichoke hearts and discover how they can elevate each other's flavors in perfect harmony. Mozzarella is always reliable due to its creamy texture which doesn't overshadow the subtle earthy notes of our star ingredient - artichoke hearts.

Pesto Sauce And Artichoke Hearts:

If traditional tomato-based sauces don't tickle your fancy, pesto sauce might be just what you need. Its robust flavors enhance those hidden sweet undertones present in cooked artichokes like no one else does.

Spinach and Feta

Your pizza night is about to get a serious upgrade. We're talking homemade spinach and feta topping, the kind of stuff that takes your ordinary cheese pizza from good to mind-blowingly delicious.

The Magic Behind Spinach and Feta Toppings

Raise The Bar With Nutrient-Rich Spinach:

This isn't just any leafy green; it's spinach we're talking about, packed with vitamins A, C, K1 among other nutrients. It wilts under oven heat, releasing its juices onto the dough, thereby enhancing both flavor and nutritional value.

KEY FACT: Spinach is known to contain high levels of vitamin C, vitamin E, vitamin K, magnesium, nitrates, lutein, zeaxanthin, beta-carotene, and folic acid, according to WebMd. (1)

Freshen Up Your Pizza Game With Tangy Feta Cheese:

Fancy some creaminess on your pie? Crumble up block feta into smaller pieces for even distribution across your homemade pizza sauce. Its salty tang will elevate all flavors without overpowering them - an absolute game-changer.

Tips for Using Spinach and Feta Cheese On Your Pizza

  • Cleanse those greens: Rinse off any dirt from fresh spinach leaves, then pat dry using paper towels;
  • Sprinkle away: Break down block feta into small chunks, ensuring equal spread over every slice;
  • Last but not least: Add these toppings last after everything else so they don't sink beneath heavier ingredients during baking time.

Getting Creative With Your Homemade Pizza Toppings

Bacon and Avo

It's time to take your homemade pizza game up a notch. Let's talk about an unexpected but delectable duo: crispy bacon and creamy avocado. This combination is set to elevate the taste of your homemade pizza, offering a delightful contrast in both flavor and texture.

Cooking Bacon for Pizza Topping

The Secret Sauce:

You might be thinking, "Bacon? That's easy." But hold on. The trick lies not just in cooking it, but cooking it right until it achieves that perfect crispiness which won't turn chewy when baked atop your pizza dough. Your skillet could do wonders here - medium heat with occasional turning should give you browned, crispy slices of heaven.

Note: Remember our goal - we're aiming for something better than good; we want great.

Selecting Avocados for Pizza Topping

A Game Changer:

Picking ripe avocados can make or break this topping combo. They need to be firm yet slightly yielding under gentle pressure indicating peak ripeness. Check out these tips on how to select perfectly ripe avocados every time.

To keep their color vibrant against high oven temperatures,

Pesto and Mushrooms: The Game Changer

Get ready to revolutionize your homemade pizza game. Pesto and mushrooms are about to take center stage on your dough, delivering a taste sensation that's going to blow you away.

The Power of Pesto

Pesto sauce, with its roots in Italy, is more than just another topping - it's the secret weapon for turning good pizzas into great ones.

Imagine basil leaves, garlic cloves, pine nuts all mixed together with Parmesan cheese and olive oil; creating an explosion of flavors that will make every bite memorable.

In our case here though? It does something even better. Serving as the base layer for our toppings - pesto creates this creamy foundation where mushrooms can sit perfectly while baking.

Four Cheeses

For pizza night to be truly special, four cheeses are a must. And when we say 'cheese', we're not just talking about your run-of-the-mill mozzarella. We're going all out with a four-cheese extravaganza that will make every homemade pizza night feel like you've stepped into an Italian pizzeria.

Mozzarella: The Classic Choice

The first contender in our quartet is none other than Mozzarella. This creamy delight sets the stage for what's to come, melting beautifully over your freshly kneaded dough and tomato sauce base, creating a stringy masterpiece that has become synonymous with well-made pizzas everywhere.

Gorgonzola: A Bold Statement

Next up on this cheesy parade is Gorgonzola - a blue-veined maestro from Italy itself. Its robust flavor profile gives your taste buds something different to dance around while complementing its fellow cheeses wonderfully.

Parmigiano Reggiano: An Unforgettable Flavor

No self-respecting cheese lover would ever forget Parmigiano Reggiano - an aged hard cheese known far and wide for its nutty undertones and unique texture. It brings balance by adding complexity against creamier elements of the pie.

Fresh Goat Cheese: Lightness Personified

Rounding off our list is fresh goat cheese; light yet flavorful enough not to be overshadowed by stronger counterparts on board. With bright citrus notes cutting through rich ingredients like home-cooked mince or caramelized onions, it adds another layer of depth without overwhelming any single element. Bonus: Your veggie pizza can now boast even more diverse flavors.

Homemade Mince

Let's take your homemade pizza to a new level of deliciousness with the addition of some delectable, satisfying home-prepared mince. It's time to elevate your culinary game.

Cooking Your Mince

Select Quality Meat:

The journey of creating an exceptional mince topping begins with choosing high-quality ground meat. Whether you prefer beef or pork, opting for lean cuts will ensure less fat content, preventing an overly greasy outcome on your pizza.

Savory Seasonings:

To truly make it stand out, season generously using salt, pepper, and Italian herbs like oregano and basil - this not only adds flavor but also brings in authenticity.

Add Flavor Enhancers

Create Depth With Additional Ingredients:

Diced onions or bell peppers sauteed along with the minced meat can enhance its taste profile significantly. Worcestershire sauce or tomato paste are other options that add savory umami notes complementing traditional toppings perfectly.

Suggested Reading: Keto Chicken Parmesan Recipe

Topping Your Pizza With Home-Cooked Mince

Perfectly Balanced Toppings:

Your gourmet creation should be balanced - too much of any one ingredient could overpower others. Spread cooled, cooked mince evenly across the pre-prepared dough base without overloading it. Remember: every bite matters.

Pair Wisely:

Pick complementary ingredients as additional toppings alongside - fresh mozzarella slices, olives perhaps? The choices are endless, possibilities limitless when it comes to crafting the perfect homemade pizza topped with deliciously rich, flavorful home-cooked mince. Happy baking.

FAQs in Relation to Homemade Pizza Toppings

What are some ideas for pizza toppings?

You can experiment with various ingredients like vegetables, fruits, different types of cheese, and meats. Some unique options include artichoke hearts, pineapple, spinach, and feta.

What are the best pizza topping combinations?

The best combinations often balance flavors. Try bacon and avocado or pesto with mushrooms. A four-cheese blend also offers a delightful mix.

What are the top 10 pizza toppings?

The top ten typically includes mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, sausage, bacon, extra cheese varieties like gorgonzola or goat's cheese; then olives and green peppers round out this list.


Exploring the world of homemade pizza toppings has never been more exciting.

From vegetables to pineapple, artichoke hearts to spinach and feta, the options are endless. Bacon and avocado bring a taste sensation while pesto and mushrooms offer a cultural mix.

The four cheese blend is an all-time favorite, but don't overlook home-cooked mince for that extra flavor punch.

Your kitchen is now your personal pizzeria where you can unleash your culinary creativity with every slice.

So why not roll up those sleeves, gather your ingredients, and get ready for an unforgettable pizza night?

If you're craving more delicious recipes or tips on perfecting that dough, head over to Tonight We Pizza at

Written By SEODave777

David Nilsson is the founder of The SEO Back Office and former SEO agency Converted Click. Passionate about people, search engines, faith, technology and boxing.

Related Posts